which player sprite looks better?

Hey JGO,
I’m new here and I have started making my first game.
The pixel art is done by both my sister & and my girlfriend and they got in a little argument about the player sprite.
which one do you think looks better?

Option 1,made by my girlfriend:

http://imageshack.com/a/img853/7398/t6pv.png

or, option 2 by my sister:

http://imageshack.com/a/img829/1707/uq5i.png

The game is in very early development so many things will change, like the background and etc so dont relay your answer too much on ther other sprites.

Thanks! :slight_smile: