Installation: +1 point if the game installs and uninstalls correctly
Stability: +1 point if the game doesn’t crash ever
Presentation: +1 point if the game is slickly presented
Graphics: +1 point if the game has “good” graphics that suit the game
Sound: +1 point if the game has “good” sound that suit the game
Style: +1 point if the game’s overall style is “good”
Innovation: +0 point if the game is original or brings a great new original twist - arena shooters are nice but not something very innovative.
Fun Factor: +0 point if your judge enjoyed playing the game - its decent but gameplay can get repetitive after a while of playing however nice for short bursts.
Completeness: +1 point if the game is complete enough that doesn’t feel anything is missing - feel that there could be more added into the game to add even more re-playability see Super Crate Box.
Freebie: +1 point if you don’t whine and you demand nothing of the mods (simply saying “can you rate my game please” is fine)
overall really and polished, IMO belongs in the featured section.