I could not actually play the game, since when I was just about to start, apparentely the connection was lost and the game exited . Maybe just return to title screen instead of closing application ??
My feedback will be a bit harsh, but I’m doing it because I think you guys achieved a nice game project so far, so take this as constructive criticism please, not the opposite .
I joined a game as observer, and from what I could observe :
The graphics look very good . The pixel art is soberb, as well as the units portraits . Some animations look kinda weird though (for example the walking animation of the mamooth like unit) . All in all the graphics look really nice .
But in my opinion the UI looks very bad . It definetely does not fit the game, and does not make justice to the rest of the graphics . From the font choice, to the buttons (like the thumbs up sign , to the shopping cart), it just looks … bad . Like a 90s windows game which used default windows fonts .
The registration page is not tester-friendly at all . You’re asking way too much information from us, the guys who are helping you testing . Don’t forget, at this point we are doing you a favor of testing your game, and you should make it easy . I’ve inserted a random email address, and when the message saying a verification email was sent, I was just about to quit testing, but tried my login without the password, which fortunately worked .
And players, in general, do not like to give lots of personal information before seeing exactly what they’re registering for . 99% of them .
I know writing in-game tutorials sucks . But don’t expect people to read a 3 page manual with tiny letters to learn how to play the game . Maybe this is just temporary while you don’t write a tutorial campaign, but I tell you, nobody will read the manual .
I know you must have put a lot of effort to reach this point, but believe me, final players don’t care how much effort you’ve put into it . If there’s a little reason for them to bitch about your game, oh yes, they will . So don’t give them reason to complain.
And forget not, polish polish polish . That’s what makes your game looks like a game, not an application .
Good luck, and good job so far. Keep it up !