Installation: +0 - I took off a point because it won’t run in Safari and took literally 18 minutes to download all of its assets and start
Stability: +0.5 points - The game didn’t crash, but after I went to the high score menu then back to the main menu and started a game, it was frozen and wouldn’t continue
Presentation: +0 - The presentation feels kind of lackluster, honestly. Could use a little bit of sprucing up.
Graphics: +1 point if the game has “good” graphics that suit the game - although I’d make your own graphics instead of lifting the Doodle Jump ones directly
Sound: +1 point if the game has “good” sound that suit the game
Style: +1 point if the game’s overall style is “good”
Innovation: +0 - A clone of Doodle Jump, so nothing new
Fun Factor: +1 point if your judge enjoyed playing the game
Completeness: +1 point if the game is complete enough that doesn’t feel anything is missing
Freebie: +1 point if you don’t whine and you demand nothing of the mods (simply saying “can you rate my game please” is fine)
6.5/10
Not featured, yet. It is what it is (a clone of Doodle Jump), but you can still be featured for sure if you fix some things. #1 most important and easiest win is to make the game start up faster than 18 minutes. That’s pretty crazy, no player is going to stick around for that. Especially because the game isn’t exactly graphically intensive. Maybe you need a faster server? The Safari problem might not even be your issue, I wouldn’t worry too much about it yet. I’d try to repro my bug that I knocked off 0.5 for stability (play the game, die, go to high scores, navigate around in them, go back to the main menu, start the game, notice it never unpause).
If you fix both of those, you’re up to an 8 which is easily featured (you only need a 7). But I’d also look to improving your presentation, generally just making the game more responsive and feel better to interact with. Right now it feels finicky and kind of… applet-y (sorry to say).
Does all that seem fair, and does it make sense?