It would be extremely cool if the winners were announces (with motivation) on an cermonly set out on the IRC at a certain time. So that we all could be there live. Just an idea, I’m sure it’s unpossible (in the words of Ralph).
Well, I really hated judging this thing. Why? I felt terrible assigning a number to so many different games of such wildly different types and skill level of the programmer. Especially when there were a few games that were so clearly above the rest in every area. Thats why I tried to give meaningful comments. When the results are announced I plan on explaining my judging method.
I’ll never judge a contest like this again.
cough hence why I suggested a public voting method (that didnt involve rating 1-100), but i got a bit flamed. oh well, I guess.
I thought the judging system was just fine
I loved this judging system. A simple, clear score, and with comments explaining the scores.
Very nice.