I seem to amplify ambiguity–am always having to expend energy cutting away options. I’d do pretty bad with an interview question like that. But to be honest, a lot has to do with not sharing the same experience or context or points of reference with the other party.
Such a situation might not be the best fit anyway. Employers with not a lot of expertise in what they are hiring for probably really do need someone who’s seen it all and can easily suss out their intentions and correct for their mistaken or limited ideas.
In other words, sometimes stupid questions are useful screening tools. I’m thinking, for example, the Nigerian Prince type scams: might as well make the initial proposal/contact full of obvious signals of the fraud involved because that fails faster with people discerning enough to likely reject the scam as they learn more about it.
In the music biz, it’s kind of like being just good enough to play really well if people around you aren’t making mistakes but being thrown if they get off, versus being good enough not to maintain and play well even when others bungle something in their parts.